By the end of his stay with Laban, Jacob is angry and indignant. And he has every right to be.

His 20 years in Laban’s household have been marred by constant manipulation and deception.

Jacob arrived as a lonely wanderer, fleeing a brother who wanted to kill him. Laban welcomed him warmly into his home, offering him safety and sanctuary. But that initial warmth soon gave way to deception. Jacob toiled for seven years, only to discover that Laban had tricked him into marrying Leah rather than Rachel. He then committed himself to a second term of seven years to marry his beloved Rachel, for whom he had already worked seven years.

Finally, after completing his years of service, Jacob asks to leave and return home.

Laban urges him to stay, acknowledging that God has blessed him through Jacob’s hard work. He offers Jacob whatever wages he requests.

(ILLUSTRATIVE) Jewish torah scroll in a synagogue in Paris, France.
(ILLUSTRATIVE) Jewish torah scroll in a synagogue in Paris, France. (credit: SHUTTERSTOCK)

Jacob reluctantly agrees to stay, displaying loyalty to a father-in-law who has done little to deserve it. He even accepts unfavorable salary terms, placing himself at a financial disadvantage.

He proposes that Laban keep the ordinary-colored sheep and goats, while Jacob will receive only those with unusual markings or coloring. This arrangement strongly favors Laban, since such animals are relatively rare. Yet Jacob deliberately chooses it to place his honesty beyond question. The distinctive appearance of his animals will make it easy to establish which belong to him and prevent any suspicion of theft.

Even then, Laban takes advantage of Jacob, removing the existing unusually colored animals and placing them three days away, making it even harder for Jacob to earn his wages.

Another six years pass, and surprisingly, Jacob has become wealthy despite the unfavorable terms of his compensation. He senses a shift in the atmosphere and growing resentment toward him within Laban’s family.

He decides on his own to return to Israel, only to be relentlessly pursued by Laban and his men, who arrive armed and prepared for violence.

At this point, Jacob has had enough. He fiercely defends his record. He reminds Laban that for 20 years he had faithfully tended his flocks, protecting them from predators, personally absorbing losses, and enduring the heat of the day and the cold of the night. Despite this extraordinary loyalty, Laban repeatedly changed his wages and exploited him, and only God’s protection prevented Jacob from leaving empty-handed.

After 20 years of mistreatment, Jacob finally refuses to remain silent, forcefully defending his family, his dignity, and the integrity he has maintained throughout these difficult years.

Jacob’s blind spot

Yet Jacob has a blind spot. He angrily rejects the possibility that anyone in his family stole Laban’s idols. He is so certain of their innocence that he declares that whoever took the idols deserves death. He has no idea that his beloved Rachel has taken them, and tragically, she would die prematurely. Our tradition connects her premature death to Jacob’s unwitting declaration.

Jacob is morally justified in virtually everything he has said. Laban has wronged him repeatedly. Yet precisely because Jacob knows how unjustly he has been treated, he cannot imagine that Laban might actually have a legitimate grievance. Jacob is right about Laban’s character. He is right about Laban’s exploitation. He is right about his own loyalty. But he is wrong about the facts of this particular accusation. Being right about the larger story does not guarantee that one is right about every part of it. His moral certainty blinded him to a truth he had never considered.

Polarization and the illusion of certainty

The more convinced we become that our views are correct, the harder it becomes to imagine that we might be wrong. And that is precisely the trap into which so much of our modern political and ideological discourse has fallen.

We live in a passionate but deeply polarized society. People care deeply about their country, their religious values, their security, their freedom, and their vision of justice. These are important convictions, and they deserve to be defended.

Unfortunately, there is increasingly little room for subtlety amid this passion. Our ideas and values become fused with our personal identities. We no longer simply hold opinions; our opinions become part of who we are. Challenging those opinions feels like challenging our identity and even our loyalty. Admitting that we may be mistaken becomes difficult because it feels like surrendering something essential about ourselves.

This polarization creates deep social divisions. Political and ideological disagreements become personal hostilities. People become increasingly suspicious of those who disagree with them. As mutual suspicion deepens, the bonds that hold society together begin to unravel.

Democratic life suffers as well. The willingness to listen, negotiate, and compromise becomes increasingly difficult when political opponents are viewed as enemies.

But polarization also creates intellectual and moral blind spots. We assume that because our broader outlook is correct, every particular opinion we hold must also be correct. We instinctively reject criticism from those who disagree with us, rarely stopping to consider whether their arguments may have some merit.

Like Jacob, we may be entirely justified in our broader position yet mistaken about something important.

It takes courage to stand up for what you believe. Sometimes, it takes even greater courage, after years of defending those beliefs, to acknowledge that you may have gotten something wrong.

Israel’s moral confidence

Do we also have our own blind spots? Our country is deeply divided over numerous ideological issues. Different camps have become so petrified in their positions that they can barely imagine there might be flaws in their own thinking. This is true of our domestic disagreements, just as it is true of our attitudes toward the outside world.

We have been fighting a war for the defense of our country and our people. We did not choose the atrocities of October 7. We have every right and every responsibility to defend our citizens and protect our future. We should never allow political polarization, external criticism, or moral confusion to erode our confidence in the justice of that cause.

We can remain deeply confident in the morality of our cause and our commitment to acting with integrity while still acknowledging that mistakes have been made. Our confidence should never prevent us from listening carefully to criticism, honestly examining our decisions, and recognizing where we may have fallen short.

Unfortunately, so much criticism of Israel is delivered with venom and imbalance. Some of it is plainly driven by hatred of our people. Amid this cacophony of hostility, it becomes difficult to distinguish reasonable voices offering constructive criticism.

We understandably become defensive, suspicious of every accusation and reluctant to listen. Yet this constant need to defend ourselves can create blind spots of its own. We may become so accustomed to rejecting unfair accusations that we lose the ability to recognize legitimate criticism when it comes our way.

The Torah tells us “Jacob did not know.” Despite all he had endured, and despite how justified he was in defending himself, there was still something he did not know.

We, too, must defend what we believe in, especially when our convictions have been tested by years of suffering and sacrifice. But we must also recognize that even when our larger cause is just, we may still overlook something important. Our confidence must be strong enough to defend our principles and humble enough to recognize our mistakes. ■

The writer is a rabbi and educator at Yeshivat Har Etzion (Gush). Find his latest book, Echoes of Rashi: Bereishit, at www.mtaraginbooks.com.