In 2009, representatives of Israel's Education Ministry acknowledged during a Knesset committee meeting that school trips exclusively to Poland could create a distorted understanding of Holocaust history. The Nazi regime originated in Germany, while the mass murder of European Jews took place across numerous countries.
Nevertheless, Poland had already become the main destination for trips organized by the ministry. In its 2011 report, the State Comptroller criticized that choice, along with the program's high cost, unequal access, and inadequate assessment of educational outcomes.
Fifteen years later, Poland remains central to Israel's school trip program.
The program has weathered diplomatic disputes, the suspension of delegations, and disagreements over historical interpretation. Efforts to develop alternative itineraries have not produced a comparable program.
Why has Poland proved so difficult to replace? And why has no full-fledged alternative emerged over the decades?
Why Poland became a main destination
In an interview with The Jerusalem Post, Dr. Yael Richler-Friedman, pedagogical director of Yad Vashem's International Institute for Holocaust Education, cited the concentration of historical sites as one of Poland's main advantages.
For Yad Vashem, it is essential that students learn not only about the death camps but also about the world that existed before the Holocaust: the culture, religious traditions, social movements, and everyday life of Jewish communities. Itineraries include Warsaw, Krakow, Auschwitz-Birkenau, Treblinka, Majdanek, Jewish cemeteries, and sites of mass shootings.
Other countries, however, offer opportunities to explore different aspects of the genocide. Germany provides a setting in which to examine the rise of Nazism, its ideology, and the state institutions that organized persecution. Lithuania and Ukraine offer insights into mass shootings outside the death camps and the involvement of local collaborators.
Why Germany, Lithuania have not replaced Poland
Poland was not always virtually the only destination. According to the State Comptroller's report, until late 2004, Israeli school delegations also visited Germany, Ukraine, the Czech Republic, and Lithuania. The Education Ministry subsequently concentrated the program on Poland.
In 2010, the possibility of resuming trips to Lithuania was discussed during a meeting between the Lithuanian ambassador and the director-general of Israel's Education Ministry. One option under consideration was adding several days in Lithuania to an existing itinerary.
In 2011, the State Comptroller criticized the Education Ministry for not sufficiently examining alternatives. In 2022, when trips to Poland were threatened by a diplomatic dispute, the ministry established an interministerial committee headed by Dr. Eli Shish.
The committee examined seven countries: Austria, Germany, Hungary, Greece, Latvia, Lithuania, and the Czech Republic. Germany, Hungary, and Lithuania were identified as potentially suitable destinations, although with limitations. Nevertheless, the committee recommended continuing trips to Poland wherever possible, treating other itineraries primarily as a fallback option if Poland became unavailable.
Similar alternatives were examined at Yad Vashem. Richler-Friedman described working groups that explored the possibility of organizing trips to Germany and Lithuania. Training had even begun for guides for the Lithuanian route. However, none of these projects developed into a comparable program.
One of the main obstacles is the training of specialists. Israeli guides accompanying delegations to Poland undergo approximately a year of training, followed by another two weeks learning how to work at the historical sites themselves.
"Imagine: a guide studies for an entire year, and then you tell him: now you're going to lead tours in Germany. You need retraining. It's very, very complicated," Richler-Friedman explained.
In Poland, by contrast, the necessary infrastructure has developed over decades. "We already have strong ties there. We know where to work and how everything is organized," she said.
After October 7, changing the established system became even more difficult. "We can start working with a guide, and then he is called up for reserve duty, and we don't see him for three months. So, we rely on what we already know how to do best."
How the 2023 agreement complicated Holocaust education trips
In 2022, Israel suspended school trips to Poland amid disagreements over security arrangements and the program's content. The dispute followed several years of tensions between the two countries, including over Polish legislation concerning historical responsibility and property claims related to the Holocaust.
In March 2023, the two countries agreed to resume the trips. It addressed security arrangements and introduced Israeli delegations to a broader context of Polish history.
A list of historical sites proposed by the Polish side sparked controversy. Delegations were required to visit at least one site from the agreed list, while retaining the ability to choose the specific location.
Yad Vashem criticized the inclusion of certain institutions that, in its assessment, could present an inaccurate account of Holocaust history.
The role of Polish society during the German occupation remained particularly sensitive. The historical record includes both Polish citizens who rescued Jews and those who participated in their persecution, denunciation, and murder.
Israel's Education Ministry rejected claims that the agreement required students to visit sites that distorted history.
At the same time, Richler-Friedman explained that Israeli guides retain independence in presenting the historical narrative, including at Auschwitz: "We can still tell the story the way we believe it should be told to Israeli students."
What do students actually gain from the trips?
School trips to Poland began in 1988, when approximately 200 teenagers participated. By 2009, the number had reached around 25,000 annually.
But the program's rapid growth was not accompanied by an equally systematic assessment of its results.
In 2011, the State Comptroller found that the Education Ministry had failed to establish a comprehensive system for evaluating the trips' educational effectiveness.
In 2007, the ministry commissioned a study from the National Authority for Measurement and Evaluation in Education (RAMA). Its findings were published in May 2011.
According to the published data, 87% of participants reported a stronger connection to Jewish history. Approximately 92% said they had gained a better understanding of Israel's significance for the Jewish people, while 85% reported feeling proud to belong to Israel.
These figures do not show how long the trips' impact lasted or whether it exceeded the results of other educational methods.
In a 2023 review, the Knesset Research and Information Center noted that, to its knowledge, the Education Ministry had not conducted a new study of the trips' effectiveness since 2011.
The preparation of students has also raised questions. In March 2025, an Israeli student was detained at the entrance to Auschwitz for a gesture interpreted as a Nazi salute, although another member of the delegation claimed he had simply been waving to a classmate. In 2018, two students were sent home after an incident involving indecent exposure at Majdanek. "We do not take this lightly," Richler-Friedman says.
Who can afford to visit Poland?
In 2009, school trips to Poland cost approximately NIS 162 million. Of that amount, parents paid around NIS 147 million, or 91%. Direct funding from the Education Ministry amounted to NIS 15 million.
The State Comptroller also found that about two-thirds of the delegations came from the most affluent third of schools, according to the ministry's socioeconomic classification.
A 2012 study found that 61% of students who did not participate cited cost as the main obstacle.
That same year, the Education Ministry introduced a subsidy program for low-income families, allocating more than NIS 50 million.
In 2014, Amram Mitzna, chairman of the Knesset Education Committee, again raised the issue of accessibility. He noted that only around 30% of students participated in the trips and called for a reassessment of Holocaust education, given that not every student could be sent abroad.
The cost of the trips continued to be raised after the State Comptroller's review. But without up-to-date statistics, it is impossible to assess how much the subsidies have changed the composition of participants or what share of the costs parents bear today.
Fifteen years after state comptroller report
Richler-Friedman said Yad Vashem maintains an ongoing dialogue with the ministry and participates in discussions about preparing students and teachers. However, the Holocaust remembrance institution does not make decisions about the organization of the government program alone.
The Education Ministry did not respond to The Jerusalem Post's inquiry about the implementation of the comptroller's recommendations, new studies, or the reasons for maintaining Poland as the exclusive destination.