Two Antwerp rabbis facing criminal charges for performing Jewish ritual circumcisions appeared before the Antwerp Court of Appeal on Monday, challenging a judge's refusal to allow further investigation into the legal and religious grounds for their prosecution.

The highly controversial case - involving Rabbi Aharon Eckstein and Rabbi David Moses Landau -  began 18 months ago when Belgian authorities raided multiple sites, including two in Antwerp’s Jewish Quarter, at the outset of an investigation into illegal circumcisions.

The Antwerp raids were prompted by a complaint from a member of the Jewish community named Moshe Friedman, who filed a police complaint against six mohels who practice metzitzah b’peh, a custom in which the circumciser cleans the circumcision wound by suctioning through a straw.

The ensuing inquest has led to mass outrage from the Jewish community, who have accused the Antwerp Public Prosecutor’s Office of “effectively criminalizing the act of circumcision” and infringing on religious freedom.

In May 2026, the Prosecutor's Office told The Jerusalem Post that there was "sufficient evidence to request that the case be referred to the criminal court for two men."

THE WRITER performs a brit milah.
THE WRITER performs a brit milah. (credit: LAURA BEN-DAVID)

The prosecution accuses the mohels of two specific offenses: Intentional, premeditated assault and battery of a minor, “several times, on unspecified dates”, by circumcising unidentified male babies in Antwerp and elsewhere in Belgium between 3 August 2024 and 10 March 2025; and unlawful practice of medicine, under the Coordinated Law of 10 May 2015 on the exercise of the healthcare professions.

Belgian authorities maintain that circumcisions must be performed by qualified medical practitioners, although the country's legislation does not explicitly address religious circumcision.

The two mohels are not licensed physicians.

Mohels demand independent brit milah expert, clarification on victims

Rabbi Landau and Rabbi Eckstein are currently challenging a July 15 decision by the Antwerp investigating judge, Paul Van Santvliet, to refuse three requests from the defense for further investigation.

The first request sought an independent expert to establish how the Royal Decree of 20 June 1820, which authorizes mohels to perform brit milah, has been applied since 1830, and whether any mohel has ever before been prosecuted for performing a ritual circumcision.

The second request was for an independent expert to explain what brit milah is, why Jewish law requires a mohel to perform it, and how it is protected by the Belgian Constitution and international law.

The third was a request for clarification of the prosecution’s list of 47 alleged victims, in which names are repeated or attributed to different mohels at the same time.

The judge rejected all three requests, and the defense asked on Monday that the Indictment Chamber reverse his decision.