Shortly before I began my latest two-week, 10-city speaking tour, a star Canadian Jewish educator warned me: “I’ve never felt such a gap between Israelis and North American Jews. Israelis can’t understand how unnerved we are by the antisemitism surrounding us, yet how vital many of our communities remain. Yet whatever Jew-hatred we’ve experienced is dwarfed by what you Israelis have sacrificed and suffered.”
I felt that gap, and experienced the contradictions, from coast to coast.
We’re living in the age of the broken covenants.
First, the world broke the post-Auschwitz covenant not to hunt down Jews: The mass demonization of Israel is despicable, as is the way haters use anti-Zionism to rationalize antisemitism, triggering attacks on synagogues, Jewish schools, Jewish-owned businesses, and individual Jews.
The world violated its “Never Again” vow. The Jews’ governments and neighbors keep breaking the unspoken contracts that unleashed such Jewish comfort and prosperity.
Jews essentially promised to be good, productive, liberal citizens, and our host countries – especially our most liberal allies – promised to protect us. I learned a new phrase – resounding in different ways worldwide.
Reeling from the election of rank antisemites like Abdul El-Sayed, shocked that so many Jews and Democrats endorsed many anti-American Jew-haters unhesitatingly, one friend wondered: “Boca or Bakka – where do we go?”
The framing may reek of privilege. But it – and the many variations on this “when’s it time to leave” question – throbs with pain.
Second, many American Jews feel Israel broke the post-1948 covenant to protect and inspire Jews:
I can disagree. We can complain that in blaming Israel for defending itself, too many Jews echo the media and the anti-Zionist maniacs currently distorting politics.
We can mock Thomas Friedman, anguished American Jews' fast-food propagandist, for false nostalgia and defining Israel – but not America – by the politicians he most hates while claiming it’s not his grandfather’s Israel – negating Israel’s remarkable progress over decades.
But when polls estimate that 56% of American Jews believe “Israel’s actions under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu have increased antisemitism and anti-Israel sentiment in the US,” those of us committed to Jewish unity should be alarmed.
Israel's failure to lead the Jewish world
Clearly, Jewish leaders, teachers, and rabbis failed to prepare their communities to understand Israel’s need to defend itself. Simultaneously, Israel’s leaders violated their Zionist mandate to lead the Jewish world effectively and constructively.
Third, many Israelis feel American Jews broke their post-1948 covenant to defend and empathize with Israel.
Global anti-Zionist manias are painful enough. But when so many American Jews internalize the lies about Israelis, it really stings.
American Jews are today’s most breast-beating, hypercritical Jews, even though only 8% are anti-Zionist. Far too many Jews embrace the blame-Israel-first narrative, holding Israel’s soldiers to standards their countries never met in Iraq, Afghanistan, or World War II.
Carp may be kosher; but such constant carping is un-Zionist. In 1911, the Zionist thinker Vladimir Ze’ev Jabotinsky envisioned “our mental emancipation,” ending “the habit of constantly feeling our pulse to see if our behavior is pleasing to others...
"The world can take us or leave us, but we will no longer spend our lives sitting in the defendant’s dock, waiting for a verdict on our right to exist.”
We have a state 115 years later, but many Jews keep tying their knickers in knots when Israelis defend themselves and anti-Zionist Jew-haters pounce.
In 1944, Jabotinsky’s rival David Ben-Gurion insisted: “We’re not building a state to escape antisemitism; we’re building a state so that the opinions of antisemites no longer govern our lives…
"We must heal ourselves of the Diaspora mentality, seeking approval from our oppressors. From now on, we write our own history.”
These ideological adversaries from yesteryear can propel us beyond today’s circular blue-and-white firing squad. We need a Zionist reset. Jew-hatred afflicts non-Jews, not most Jews; so let non-Jews bankrupt themselves fighting antisemitism.
Let’s rebalance our communal spending, instead maximizing Jewish education and immersive identity-building experiences.
Too many Israel conversations are headline-driven, not values-laden, perverting our Jewish identities, not just our Zionist identities. American Jews keep defining themselves and framing too many communal debates based on their bogus bible – The New York Times – not the real thing.
Their character education emphasizes fitting in and getting ahead overseas rather than standing tall and feeling rooted in our homeland, wherever we live. And their Zionism ends up branded by Bibi, Biden, or Trump, not the sacred mission “to be a free people in our homeland, the land of Zion.”
In 1892, Ahad Ha’am took “half comfort” in the fanatical antisemitism threatening Jews. The blood libel was so absurd that Jews repudiated it.
As Jews integrated into society, however, he feared they would absorb the subtler, equally devastating lies bombarding them. Increasingly consensus-driven, they would think: “if ‘the whole world’ believes it to be so, then surely it is so.”
How prescient he was!
The only cure for that other-driven malady and the secret to Jewish reunification is Identity Zionism, ideological Pilates. Wherever we live, we fortify ourselves and our children against the mob, rooting them in our 3,500-year-old story overflowing with goodness and our 78-year-old state brimming with virtues.
This month, I’ve seen Jews steeped in that story in Chabad of Westmount, Chicago’s Rochelle Zelle Hebrew High School, Beth El Synagogues from Baltimore to Chicago, American Israel Public Affairs Committee's activists, Hillel heroes, Birthright Israel’s leaders.
Such counter-cultural programming will not only save Jews worldwide – it will also save the West from its worst excesses and from the enemies it keeps welcoming within and electing to higher office.
The writer is a distinguished scholar of North American history at McGill University and a senior research fellow at the Jewish People Policy Institute. He is the author of nine books on presidential history and nine on modern Zionism, including To Resist the Academic Intifada: Letters to My Students on Defending the Zionist Dream, as well as his latest e-book, The Essential Guide to the US-Israel Partnership: the 250th Anniversary Edition.